Goodreads has temporarily disabled rating and reviewingHillbilly Elegy , the memoir of republican Vice Presidential nominee JD Vance . Asfirst reported by 404 Media , drug user who try are met with a popup letting them bang they ca n’t . “ This book has temporary limitation on submitting ratings and reviews , ” the popup says . “ This may be because we ’ve discover strange behavior that does n’t survey our review guidepost . ”
attain by phone , Goodreads pointed Gizmodo to the popup on its web site and turn down to point out further on the matter .
A junior Senator from Ohio , Vance ’s list of eccentric and awful yield is long . He ’s said that the U.S. postulate a “ de - Ba’athification ” program , reason that day nest egg timehurts womanhood ’s fertility , and in earnest partake his opinion thatStar warfare : The Last Jediwas a “ cruel movie . ”
Credit: Gaelen Morse/Bloomberg via Getty Images
But before all that he was selling out his “ hillbilly ” family in Appalachia in a bestselling 2016 memoir . The book detail Vance ’s early life , his female parent ’s struggle with drug dependence , and his high - falutin public opinion on the white rural poor people he claimed as his own . The Word of God was a smash collision . masses in Appalachiahated it . Netflix ferment it into a film star Glenn Close and Amy Adams that critic hated .
People often evince their displeasure at artists and writers on on-line review platforms . web site that allow substance abuser ratings ( like Rotten Tomatoes , Metacritic , and Steam ) face a trouble where drug user leave disconfirming review of a piece of music of fine art because they ’re mad at the Divine or tied up in some freakish culture state of war nonsense . It ’s called critique bombing , and it happens all the sentence .
Goodreads has been at the nerve center of many follow-up bombardment controversies over the years . No one is more criminal to each other online thanyoung adult book fans . To combat review bombing , Goodreads launched a system in October of 2023 that temporarily halts user reviews when it detects review post that it believes plunder its road map .
Goodreadsannounced the raw systemin a web log post last yr . Hillbilly Elegyis not the first fourth dimension it ’s been deploy . In December , ithad limit reviewson the bookIsraelby Noa Tishby . In March , itdid the samefor the bookTo Gaze Upon Wick Godsby Molly X Chang .
Users on Amazon , which owns Goodreads , are not face a standardised restriction . The recent followup ofHillbilly Elegyon Amazon are full of 1 and 5 - star review .
“ This ledger is much like the man who wrote it- scraps , ” aver a one - superstar review posted on July 16 . “ It is inflammatory towards great deal people , so coarse and critical and lacks any basic intellect of post industrial collapse in a realm that is prevalent with political oppression and lack of delegacy , canonical infrastructure , and outside corporation as absentee landowners that pay little to no revenue enhancement to support the local community base . commix this with the landscape and of course you have a live group of people wear off down to admit their lot in life with fiddling ways to convert their reality . ”
For anyone looking to read the historic and economical pressures that shaped Appalachia , may I suggestNight Comes to the Cumberlands ?
Amazon
Daily Newsletter
Get the best technical school , scientific discipline , and culture news in your inbox daily .
newsworthiness from the future , deliver to your present .
You May Also Like
